Humidifiers vs dehumidifers vs air purifiers | CHOICE

2022-06-22 10:07:19 By : Mr. William Wu

The air in your home can have a big impact on how you feel and whether you're comfortable in your house. Things like itchy skin, sneezing and mildew can be signs that you might need an appliance to treat the air in your home. 

But the options are many and confusing: humidifier, dehumidifier or air purifier? Refrigerant or desiccant? Warm or cool mist? HEPA or carbon filters?

Many of these appliances aren't cheap, so it's important to understand how they work to make sure you're buying the right one for your needs. 

We'll explain how each appliance works and how to tell if you need one.

We've tested to find you the best.

When the cold weather hits and it's time to crank up the heater, you might find you're struggling with dry skin and chapped lips. That's because some heaters (and air conditioners too) can really dry out the air. 

If the humidity is too low in your home, you'll notice more static electricity in the air and you might suffer from dry skin, eye irritation, nasal dryness and allergy symptoms.

Humidifiers can help some allergies and skin conditions that are exacerbated by dry air

Humidifiers transform water into water vapour and disperse it through a room to help increase the humidity level. 

Most importantly, they can help some allergies and skin conditions that are exacerbated by dry air. Some people find them helpful for relieving cold symptoms or other respiratory conditions, and can help you get a better night's sleep while you're unwell. 

There are different types of humidifiers, some of which aren't suitable for every situation. Read more about  what you need to know when buying a humidifier for your home. 

A vaporiser is similar to a humidifier in that it puts moisture back into the air, but it does it in a different way. 

"The main difference is that a vaporiser uses steam as the way to get moisture into the air," says CHOICE expert Denis Gallagher. 

"By contrast, a humidifier uses mist, which may or may not be visible. A vaporiser releases a lot of steam into the air, while the humidifier is a bit more measured."

Read more: Do humidifiers help with colds and allergies?

With La Niña dumping large quantities of water across Australia this year, dehumidifiers were in high demand as people needed to dry out their homes, either from water ingress and leaks or just the humidity. 

Signs of high humidity in your home are condensation on windows, wet patches on walls, a musty smell, dust mites, and mould and mildew in the bathroom and on surfaces throughout your home (including your clothes and soft furnishings). 

Dust mites and mould are two common triggers for asthma and allergy, so it's important to stay on top of them if you have any sensitive people living in your home.

You might need a dehumidifier if your home has damp problems, you've been affected by floods or water leaks, or you have mould throughout your home.

Dehumidifiers work in the opposite way to humidifiers – they take moisture from the air to reduce the humidity. You might need one if your home has damp problems, if you've been affected by floods or water leaks, or if you're finding mould and mildew throughout your home. 

Dehumidifiers are also great if you need to dry your laundry indoors – they can speed up the drying process, as well as reduce condensation and the likelihood of mould developing from the moisture in the air. Some dehumidifiers even have a laundry setting. 

Want to know more? We'll explain the different types of dehumidifiers and how to use them in our dehumidifier buying guide. 

Our expert dehumidifier reviews  include information about features, running costs and capacity, and allow you to sort by humidifier type, brand and price to help you choose the right model for you.

Read more: What does a dehumidifier do and is it worth getting one?

We've tested to find you the best.

When large parts of the east coast were affected by terrible bushfires in 2019, many families used air purifiers to remove smoke particles that were choking the air. 

They're invaluable for families who suffer from asthma and allergies as they can reduce symptoms caused by airborne allergens. They can also remove nasties like viruses, bacteria and mould spores – although there are some limitations. (See our article on how air purifiers deal with viruses and bacteria.)

Air purifiers are invaluable for families who suffer from asthma and allergies as they can reduce symptoms caused by airborne allergens

Air purifiers are quite different to humidifiers and dehumidifiers in that they don't affect humidity levels. Instead, they draw in air from a room and filter it to remove pollutants like dust, pollen, pet dander, smoke particles, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), mould spores and germs. They then circulate the cleaned air back into the room. 

You might need an air purifier for these reasons:

Getting the right air purifier for your needs is important to your family's health. Our expert explains what to look for when buying an air purifier for your home. 

Our expert air purifier reviews include useful information about running costs, capacity and replacement filter costs, plus you can narrow your search by price, filter type and pollutant removal score to make sure you're buying the best model for your needs. 

To share your thoughts or ask a question, visit the CHOICE Community forum.

Stay informed. Get the latest product reviews, money-saving tips and more.

We at CHOICE acknowledge the Gadigal people, the traditional custodians of this land on which we work, and pay our respects to the First Nations people of this country. CHOICE supports the First Nations people's Uluru Statement from the Heart.